The Evolution of Southeast Asian Regionalism: Security, Economic Development and Foreign Power Support for Regional Initiatives, 1947-77

Sue Thompson

doi:10.21512/jas.v5i1.4160

Authors

Sue Thompson Australian National University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21512/jas.v5i1.4160

Keywords:

regionalism, Southeast Asia, economic development, security

Abstract

Policy objectives for Southeast Asian regionalism had been evolving since the end of the Second World War. Economic development viewed as essential for establishing peace and stability in Southeast Asia and the links between development and security were evident in the elaboration of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). Also evident was the second-line support provided by external powers. While ASEAN was a regional initiative that came out of the Bangkok talks to end Confrontation, Western governments had been formulating regional cooperation policies in Southeast Asia decades prior. Economic development viewed as essential for containing communist influence and preventing internal insurgencies in the region. Growth and prosperity would come through regional development programs with external support. This would then expand to some form of collective security led by the Southeast Asian nations themselves. Regionalism viewed as one way of providing economic assistance to newly independent nations without the appearance of foreign interference in regional affairs. Therefore, the evolution of Southeast Asian regionalism was a combined effort of foreign power support for Asian initiatives throughout the economic development with the aim to provide security during the political transformation of the region from the post-war period into the early years of ASEAN and the aftermath of the war in Vietnam.

Dimensions

Plum Analytics

Author Biography

Sue Thompson, Australian National University

National Security College, Crawford School of Public Policy

References

Primary Source Archival Material

Letter, H.V. Evatt to Nelson T. Johnson, 24 February 1944, A989, 44/735/168/20, NAA & Cablegram, Bruce to Curtin, 10 November 1944, A989,44/630/5/l/11/22, National Archives of Australia (NAA).

Memorandum, for Butterworth and Fisher, 15 July 1949, Box 5, John F. Melby Papers, China File, Publications, General, Box 5, Harry S. Truman Library (HSTL).

Memorandum, Secretary of State and Butterworth, 16 January 1950, John F. Melby Papers, China File, Publications, General, Box 5, HSTL.

Memorandum, Landon to Rostow, 6 March 1961, National Security Files, Countries, Laos General, Box 130, John F. Kennedy Library (JFKL).

Minute, A.J. de la Mare to Mr Samuel, 23 January 1967, FCO 15/18 and Foreign Office Memorandum, July 1966, FO 371/187566, The National Archives (United Kingdom) (TNA).

Administrative History of the Department of State during the Administration of President Lyndon B. Johnson, November 1963-January 1969, Volume I, Administrative History, Department of State, Volume I, Chapters 7-9, Box 3, Lyndon Baines Johnson Library (LBJL).

Conversation between Ball and Talbot, 22 February 1965, Papers of George W. Ball, Indonesia, National Security File, Box, 4, LBJL.

Talking Points for Bundy from Chester L. Cooper on A Regional Development Proposal for Southeast Asia, National Security File, Country File Vietnam, Box 54, LBJL.

Rusk to Rev. Henry Van Dusen, 10 September 1965, Central Policy Files 1964-66, Political Affairs and Relations, RG 59, Box 1897, National Archives at College Park (NARA).

Washington to Singapore, 23 November 1965, Box 1803, Central Policy Files 1964-66, Political Affairs and Relations, RG 59, Box 1803, NARA.

Memorandum for Rostow from William J. Jorden on Elements of Progress in Asia, 24 June 1966, National Security File, Name File, Box 5, LBJL.

Memorandum from Ropa to Rostow, 11 April 1966, National Security File, Name File, Box 7, LBJL.

Administrative History of the Department of State during the Administration of President Lyndon B. Johnson, November 1963-January 1969, Volume I, Administrative History, Department of State, Volume I, Chapters 7-9, Box 3, LBJL.

British Embassy in Washington Aide Memoire on The Western Position in South East Asia, 13 February 1964, National Security File, Country File, Vietnam, Box 53, LBJL.

Record of discussion between Rusk and Stewart, 14 May 1965, FO 371/180439, TNA.

Kuala Lumpur to Ottawa, 22 February 1966, FCO 15/18, TNA.

Memorandum, N. Pritchard to Lord Beswick, 20 May 1966, FO 371/187564, TNA.

London to certain missions, 26 May 1966, FO 371/187564, TNA.

Ropa to Rostow, 28 July 1966, Name File, Ropa Memos, National Security File, Box 7, LBJL.

Kuala Lumpur to London, 3 June 1966, FO 371/187565, TNA.

Jakarta to Washington, 27 May 1966, Foreign Relations of the U.S. (FRUS) 1964-68, p. 432.

Record of meeting between Colin Jackson MP, Tam Dalyell MP and General Suharto, 2 June 1966, PREM 13/1058, TNA.

Kuala Lumpur to Washington, 3 June 1966, Central Policy Files 1964-66, Political Affairs and Relations, RG 59, Box 2452, NARA.

Kuala Lumpur to Canberra, 30 May 1966, A1209, 1964/67/15, NAA.

Kuala Lumpur to Washington, 13 June 1966, Central Policy Files 1964-66, Political Affairs and Relations, RG 59, Box 2452, NARA.

Washington to Kuala Lumpur, 12 October 1966, Central Files 1964-66, Political Affairs and Relations, RG 59, Box 2453, NARA.

Vice-president to Johnson, 5 January 1966, Name File - Vice-president Volume I, National Security File, Box 4, LBJL.

Record of conversation between Rusk and Thanat Khoman, 28 June 1966, Central Policy Files 1964-66, Political Affairs and Relations, RG 59, Box 1898, NARA.

Jakarta to Canberra, 3 March 1967, A4359/14, 221/5/22 part 1, NAA.

National Intelligence Committee (NIC) 303(74), First Draft, 5 July 1974, A1838, 3004/13/21 part 28, NAA.

Washington to Canberra, 17 August 1967, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Kuala Lumpur to Canberra, 26 May 1967, A1838, 3004/13/21 part 1, NAA.

Washington to Canberra, 17 August 1967, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Canberra to all posts, 5 September 1967, A1838, 3004/13/21 Part 3, NAA.

Washington to Canberra, 17 August 1967, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Canberra to certain posts, 9 August 1967, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Canberra to all posts, 5 September 1967, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Talking points for meeting with Malik, by Kissinger, 24 September 1974, National Security Adviser, Presidential Country Files for Asia and the Pacific, Indonesia, Box 6, Gerald R. Ford Library (GRFL).

Kuala Lumpur to Canberra, 17 December 1969, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Record of meeting between Wilson and Nixon, 3 August 1969, PREM 13/3027, TNA.

President Richard Nixon Statement on the Asian Development Bank, Philippines, 27 July 1969, Melvin R. Laird Papers, 1953-2004, Department of Defense Papers; Baroody Subject File, SALT, 1968-1972, Box A90, GRFL.

William P. Rogers speech before the national Press Club, Canberra, 8 August, 1969, Melvin R. Laird Papers, Department of Defense Papers: Baroody Subject File, SALT, 1968-192, Box A90, GRFL.

White House Press Statement, 25 February 1970, NSC Files, Subject Files, Asia Development Bank, Box 308, Nixon Presidential Library (NPL).

Singapore to Washington, 14 November 1969, Central Policy Files 1967-69, Defense, RG 59, Box 1518, NARA.

Memorandum, Kissinger to Agnew, December 1969, NSC Files, Henry A. Kissinger Office Files, Country Files – Far East, Box 82, NPL.

Memorandum, East Asia and the Pacific, Background on Regional Cooperation, 8 December 1969, NSC Files, Henry A. Kissinger Office Files, Country Files – Far East, Box 82, NPL.

Manila to Canberra, 2 January 1970, A5882/CO818, NAA.

Bangkok to Canberra, 18 November 1969, A1838, CO67/1/4/41 Part 1, NAA.

NIC Note 4/70, 14 October 1970, A1838 3001/1/7/ Part 1, NAA.

National Security Decision Memorandum 126, 11 August 1971, National Security Adviser, NSC East Asian and Pacific Affairs Staff Files, (1969) 1973-1976, Subject File: Kissinger Memcons (5), Box 15, GRFL.

Kuala Lumpur to Canberra, 2 January 1970, A5882/CO818, NAA.

Singapore to Canberra, 3 January 1970, A5882/CO818, NAA.

Jakarta, Kuala Lumpur, Singapore to Canberra, 2 January 1970, A5882, CO818, NAA.

Kissinger memorandum for the Secretary of State and Secretary of Defense, 11 March 1970, Kissinger-Scowcroft West Wing Office Files, 1969-1977, General Subject File: Indonesia, Box 14, GRFL.

Memorandum of Conversation between Sumitro and Kissinger, 1 July 1970, Kissinger-Scowcroft West Wing Office Files, 1969-1977, General Subject File: Indonesia, Box 14, GRFL.

Memorandum of Conversation between Sumitro and Kissinger, 8 July 1970, Kissinger-Scowcroft West Wing Office Files, 1969-1977, General Subject File: Indonesia, Box 14, GRFL.

Memorandum, John H. Holdridge to Kissinger, 13 October 1970, Kissinger-Scowcroft West Wing Office Files, 1969-1977, General Subject File: Indonesia, Box 14, GRFL.

Memorandum, John H. Holdridge and Richard T. Kennedy to Kissinger, 18 November 1970, Kissinger-Scowcroft West Wing Office Files, 1969-1977, General Subject File: Indonesia, Box 14, GRFL.

NIC 1(70), 9 September 1970, A452, 1970/4122, NAA.

W.I. Combs, British Ambassador to Indonesia to Foreign Office, 15 November 1971, FCO 24/1019, TNA.

Speech by British Ambassador Mr C.M. Maclehose to Lions Club of Saigon, 24 February 1969, A1838, 67/1/4/41 Part 1, NAA.

NIC 124(72), 4 August 1972, A1838, 683/72/124, NAA.

Canberra to Australian posts, 29 August 1972, A1838, 67/1/4/41 Part 2, NAA.

NIC 303(74), 2 September 1974, A1838, 3004/13/21 Part 28, NAA.

NIC 124(72), First Draft, 25 July 1972, A1838, 683/72/125, NAA.

Memorandum, Kissinger to Ford, 1 July 1975, Box 11, National Security Adviser Presidential Briefings Material for VIP visits, 1974-1976, GRFL.

NIC 57(73), September 1973, A1838, 683/72/57, NAA.

Response to Proposed Parliamentary Question on ASEAN by A.M. Simons, South-East Asia Department, 17 January 1977, FCO 15/2249, TNA.

Memorandum of conversation between President Nixon and General Sunthorn, SEATO Secretary General, 21 September 1973, FRUS, 1969-76, Vol. E-12, Documents on East and Southeast Asia, 1973-76, Washington, 2011.

Department of State Briefing Paper, Januar 1974, Box 65, Ford Vice-Presidential Papers, Office of Assistant for Defense and International Affairs Files, 1973-1974, John O. Marsh, GRFL.

Letter, Paris to Canberra, 11 September 1973, A1838, 683/72/57, NAA.

Record of Conversation, S. Rajaratnam and Don Willesee, 15 November 1973, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Draft Department of Foreign Affairs Paper on ASEAN, 16 December 1975, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Response to Proposed Parliamentary Question on ASEAN by A.M. Simons, South-East Asia Department, 17 January 1977, FCO 15/2249, TNA.

Jakarta to Canberra, 9 May 1974, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Draft Department of Foreign Affairs Paper on ASEAN, 16 December 1975, A9564, 221/4/16, NAA.

Memorandum, Scowcroft to Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, Director of Central Intelligence, US Interests and Objectives in the Asia-Pacific Region – Part 1, NSSM 235, 5 November 1976, NSC Institutional Files, NSSM 231, Box 39, GRFL.

FCO paper on British Policy Towards the Countries of ASEAN, July 1977, FCO 15/2249, TNA.

Interdepartmental Committee on ASEAN, Information Paper, 9 September 1977, FCO 15/2247, TNA.

Books, Book Sections, Journal Articles, and Newspapers

Acharya, A. (2012). The making of Southeast Asia: International relations of a region. Singapore: ISEAS.

Anwar, D. F (1994). Indonesia in ASEAN: Foreign policy and regionalism. Singapore: ISEAS.

Buszynsky, L. (1981). SEATO: Why it survived until 1977 and why it was abolished. Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 12(2), 287-296.

Gill, R. (1997) ASEAN towards the 21st century: A thirty-year review of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations. London: ASEAN Academic Press.

Lee Kuan Yew, (2000). From Third World to First: The Singapore Story: 1965-2000. Singapore: Singapore Press Holdings.

Mitcham, C (2012). Australia and development cooperation at the United Nations: Towards poverty reduction. In J. Cotton & D. Lee (eds.), Australia and the United Nations. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.

Narine, S. (1998). ASEAN and the management of regional security. Pacific Affairs, 71(2), 198-201.

Tarling, N, (2006). Regionalism in Southeast Asia: To foster the political will. London: Routledge.

The Hobart Mercury, 22 February 1973.